

I have found that with many biographical pop music musicals that they are, as one would expect, chocker-block full of the artists’ songs but they are very skimpy in relation to giving us real insights in to the artist behind the ‘masterpieces’.
Thankfully, in this respect, NEIL DIAMOND THE MUSICAL : BEAUTIFUL NOISE is different. This has much to do with the way the musical has been structured.
The play has been structured around long time therapy sessions that Diamond, now a frail, elderly man, undertakes as he reflects on his life and his music career which spanned over six decades.
The show reveals that Diamond has undertaken therapy at this late stage to combat the funk that he has gotten in to after being told that he has Parkinson’s and will no longer be able to tour. In many respects his music career had defined him, as indeed many of us are defined by our working lives.
The therapist Marsha brings a copy of the book The complete lyrics of Neil Diamond and together they start exploring his career’s journey and his rich song catalogue. We then regularly switch between the present in the therapy room, and the past as Will Swenson, the troupe and the band, gloriously sing and dance their way through many of his songs. What a catalogue! Song highlights included Sweet Caroline, Cracklin’ Rosie, Song Song Blue, Holly Holy, Cherry, Cherry, You Don’t Bring Me Flowers, Shilo and Crunchy Granola.
The cast were excellent; the principals, the supporting cast and the ensemble.
Will Swenson was as Neil Diamond in his prime, and Terrence Crawford was fantastic as the elderly Diamond looking back on his life. One of my favourite scenes in the show was when the two men, facing each other, singing a duet, the past and present meeting each other, at some middle point.
Monica Sayers impressed as Diamond’s very empathetic therapist who guides him on a journey to a better understanding of himself.
Jaye Posner played Diamond’s first wife who was very supportive in the start and establishment of his career. Ashleigh Rubenach was superb, what a beautiful voice, as Diamond’s very loving wife who Diamond neglected as his career saw him always on the road. Rubenach
Hannah Fredericksen was great as Elle Greenwich, a a songwriter and record producer who recognised Diamond’s talent in an audition she gave him at New York’s famous Brill building. Fredericksen also played Diamond’s mother, Rose.
Production values were strong with Liam Mcilwain being the resident director , Nigel Ubrihien the music director, and Nicholas Eaton, the resident choreographer.
We were all won over. For the encore it was of-course Sweet Caroline. I looked around and nearly everyone, including those in the rafters, were waving their arms to the beat of this song which has had just under 2 billions hits on Spotify.
By the show’s end, I had formed a bit of a picture of the Neil Diamond story. As a youngster he was an unassuming, introverted, sensitive man with a prodigious musical talent.
He had to be pushed to perform his own songs rather than give them to known singers of the time.
When he started churning out hits, the music producers wanted him to continue just coming out with pop tunes, but he wanted to be more experimental and stayed true to his path.
Diamond was surprised at the rate his career took off, and mostly went with the flow, though he had his battles with depression. He didn’t like to talk about these ‘blues’. Through the show the therapist Marcia brings up the song, ‘I am I said’, and he is gruff and defensive about it, paraphrasing, ‘I don’t walk to talk about that song or that time of my life.’
I was left with two contrasting images of Diamond. There was the pop artist playing large crowds dressed in sequinned tops. And then there was the artist who wrote the song, Solitary Man –‘I am what I am/ A solitary man’.
I guess it comes down to this. One is the public persona, and the other is the private man. Now that he doesn’t have to be on show any more, he can now enjoy some solitude, and time with those he loves, as health issues come to the fore as we age.
THE NEIL DIAMOND MUSICAL : A BEAUTIFUL NOISE , with book by Anthony McCarten, is playing Sydney as part of a national tour. It has already been to Melbourne. It is currently playing the Sydney Lyric at the Star until 14th February 2027. It then travels for seasons at the Lyric theatre, Queensland Performing Arts Centre from March 20 and then Her Majesty’s theatre, Adelaide from May 23, 2027.
Production photography by Jeff Busby
http://www.theneildiamondmusical.com.au
http://www.ticketmaster.com.au